Are you looking for the best dog activity tracker to monitor your pup’s health and fitness? PitPat and FitBark are two of the most popular options.
But how do you choose between them?
In this in-depth comparison review, we’ll compare PitPat and FitBark across 10 key factors:
- Battery life
- Waterproof rating
- Tracking accuracy
- Data storage
- App interface
- Support and warranty
- Extra features
- Our top pick
We’ll help you decide which dog activity tracker best fits your needs and budget.
A Quick Comparison of PitPat vs FitBark
Before we dive into the details, here is a quick overview of how PitPat and FitBark stack up:
|£39 one-time payment
|£56 one-time payment
|Simple, easy to use
|More detailed, data heavy
|Support & Warranty
|1 year warranty
|1 year warranty
|Badges and points for goals
|Social media integration
|Check Price at Amazon
|Check Price at Amazon
As you can see, both devices match up well across most categories. The main differences are cost, battery life, data storage, and app interface.
Now let’s explore each factor in-depth so you can make an informed decision.
Cost: PitPat is More Affordable Upfront
The first consideration for most pet owners is cost. PitPat is the more affordable option at £39 for the device compared to £56 for the FitBark.
However, the FitBark battery lasts 6 months while the PitPat battery lasts a full year. So in a 2 year period, you’d spend:
- PitPat: £39
- FitBark: £56 + £28 for 2 extra batteries = £84
Over time, the costs even out. But if you want to minimize your upfront investment, the PitPat is cheaper.
There are no required monthly subscription fees for either device.
Winner: PitPat for one-time cost, but long term costs are comparable.
Battery Life: PitPat Lasts Longer
The PitPat uses a replaceable CR2032 coin cell battery that lasts an impressive 1 year before it needs to be swapped out.
The FitBark has a built-in rechargeable lithium polymer battery that provides 6 months of battery life per charge.
Replacing batteries is less convenient than recharging, but the 1 year span for the PitPat means less frequent battery maintenance. You’ll go through 2 batteries over the same time period that a FitBark would need recharged 4 times.
If you don’t mind recharging more often, the FitBark may suit you. But for maximum convenience, the longer lasting PitPat battery has an advantage.
Winner: PitPat for longer battery life.
Waterproof Rating: Both Are Waterproof
Good news – both the PitPat and FitBark have an IP67 waterproof rating.
This means they can withstand being submerged in 1 meter of water for up to 30 minutes without damage.
So you can let your dog swim and play in the water without worrying about ruining the tracker.
Verdict: Tie since both offer excellent waterproofing.
Durability: Both Withstand Dog Abuse
Durability is crucial for a dog gadget that will get tossed around. The PitPat and FitBark are both built to withstand doggie antics.
The PitPat case is hardened plastic and rubber with a rugged design. The Velcro strap keeps it securely fastened. It’s dog-proof and built for adventures.
The FitBark has a tough polycarbonate shell and industrial strength zip tie mounts. The snug fit ensures it stays on despite running and rough play.
Both trackers can handle being chomped on by curious canines thanks to their durable construction. They are designed specifically with dogs in mind.
While accidents happen, these trackers are some of the most heavy duty options out there.
Verdict: Tie since both offer excellent durability for dogs.
Tracking Accuracy: Precise Step and Activity Tracking
When it comes to accurately tracking your dog’s activity levels, both devices deliver excellent results.
They each use a 3-axis accelerometer to precisely track steps taken, distance travelled, calories burned, and sleep quality.
The PitPat recognizes different intensities of activity like walking, running, playing, resting and idle time.
The FitBark measures activity on a minute-by-minute basis and assigns point values to determine how close your dog is to reaching their activity goals.
Multiple dog parents report reliable results from both brands when it comes to monitoring their dog’s fitness and health. They provide insightful data you can trust.
Verdict: Tie since both devices offer precise multi-metric tracking.
Data Storage: FitBark Stores More History
The number of days of data that can be stored before syncing with your smartphone app differs between the brands.
The PitPat can hold up to 7 days of activity stats before needing to manually sync.
The FitBark doubles that with the capacity to store 100 days of minute-by-minute data. That’s over 3 months worth!
For maximum historical insights, the FitBark is the winner here. But 7 days is sufficient for most purposes.
Winner: FitBark for significantly longer onboard data storage.
App Interface: PitPat is More User Friendly
While both brands offer free mobile apps to sync your tracker with, they differ quite a bit in their interface and user experience.
The PitPat app prioritizes simplicity and ease of use. The straightforward dashboard displays daily and weekly stats like activity time, calories burned and distance covered in simple graphs and charts.
The FitBark app dives deeper into the data, with detailed graphs and visualizations analyzing activity levels, calories, sleep scores and more. It can feel overwhelming compared to the PitPat.
So it depends on your priorities. If you want an easy, user-friendly app, PitPat is the winner. For maximum data analysis, FitBark has the edge.
Winner: PitPat for simpler, more beginner friendly app.
Support and Warranty: Both Have 1 Year Coverage
You want peace of mind in case anything goes wrong with your dog tracker. Both PitPat and FitBark provide a 1 year warranty against defects.
This means if your device malfunctions through no fault of your own in the first year, you can get a replacement.
Make sure to register your warranty online after purchasing. Then keep your receipt, as you’ll need to provide proof of purchase for warranty claims.
It’s reassuring to have this coverage in case you encounter issues like connectivity problems, app glitches or hardware defects.
Verdict: Tie since both come with 1 year warranties.
Extra Features: Badges vs Social Sharing
Beyond just fitness tracking, each company includes their own unique set of bonus features.
The PitPat app awards you badges and points for hitting activity milestones. You can redeem points for discounts on dog products and other prizes. It’s a fun gamification element.
The FitBark allows you to connect with other owners through their “Bark Community” for photo sharing and commenting. It integrates with your existing social media accounts. The gamification of PitPat is similar to what we observed in our FitBark review.
Which extra you’ll get more from depends on your motivations. If you like friendly competition and rewards, PitPat has the advantage. For social engagement, FitBark is the winner.
Both provide extra ways to engage with the app beyond just seeing data. It comes down to your preferences.
Verdict: Tie since both have fun bonus features.
Our Top Pick: PitPat Offers the Best Value
When all is said and done, which dog activity tracker comes out on top?
For its combination of affordability, long battery life, durable design, user-friendly app and engaging bonus features, our top pick is the PitPat.
It provides the core fitness tracking functionality pet owners need in a rugged, waterproof device built to survive dog ownership.
The straightforward app and long-lasting battery minimize maintenance. And extras like achievement badges make it fun and motivating to use.
While the FitBark does offer longer data history and social sharing capabilities, the PitPat gives you the essential activity tracking features at a more wallet-friendly price point.
For these reasons, the PitPat is our recommendation as the best dog activity monitor available today. The value for money is unmatched.
Factors to Consider When Choosing a Dog Activity Tracker
To determine which option best suits your needs, here are the key factors to consider:
Your budget – PitPat is more affordable upfront. But FitBark’s replaceable batteries even out long term costs.
Convenience – PitPat batteries last 1 year vs 6 month recharges for FitBark. But recharging avoids replacements.
Fitness tracking needs – Both track steps, calories, sleep. FitBark stores more historical data.
App interface – PitPat simpler and easier to use. FitBark provides more detailed analytics.
Dog size – Both work for dogs of all sizes but PitPat lighter for smaller dogs.
Social engagement – FitBark better if you want social features. PitPat better for motivation and rewards.
Prioritize what matters most – convenience, budget, app usability, or social connections. Then choose the tracker that best aligns with your preferences.
For more on top GPS pet trackers like Whistle and Tractive, see our in-depth comparison.
The Bottom Line
Dog activity trackers like PitPat and FitBark are game changers for monitoring your pup’s fitness and keeping them healthy.
They empower you to catch potential issues early and optimize exercise and rest for your dog’s needs.
In this detailed comparison guide, we broke down the key similarities and differences between two top options – the PitPat and FitBark trackers.
While both provide robust fitness tracking, our top overall pick is the PitPat for its unbeatable combination of value, convenience and user-friendly design.
But you can’t go wrong with either option. Hopefully this guide gave you the insights needed to decide which fits your priorities.
Whichever you choose, this technology lets you become a better pet parent. Your dog will thank you!
Frequently Asked Questions
Do dog activity trackers replace vet visits?
No. Dog activity trackers are useful for monitoring between vet visits, but not a replacement for professional veterinary care and annual exams. Always consult your vet if you notice major changes.
Are dog fitness trackers safe?
Yes, PitPat and FitBark undergo rigorous safety testing. But supervise your dog at first when getting used to any new collar device. Remove if they try chewing it.
Do I need a smartphone to use them?
Yes, a smartphone is required to sync the tracker via Bluetooth and view data in the app. Both work with iOS and Android.
How accurate are they for small dogs?
Very accurate. Both brands work for dogs of all sizes. The measurements adjust automatically. PitPat is lighter which can be better for toy breeds.
Can I swim with my dog while they wear it?
Yes, both PitPat and FitBark are waterproof with IP67 ratings, so swimming and water play are no problem.
How long does the battery last?
The PitPat battery lasts 1 year. The FitBark battery provides 6 months of use before needing recharged.
Do they track location or work as GPS?
No, these are activity trackers only. They do not track location or work as GPS to locate your dog if lost. For that, you need a separate GPS tracker.
Will my dog even notice wearing one?
Most dogs don’t notice or mind wearing the small, lightweight trackers. But always supervise your dog at first when getting used to any new collar accessory.