Remote training collars like the Dogtra 1900S and ARC are powerful tools for reinforcing obedience in dogs. But with so many models available, how do you choose the right e-collar?
In this in-depth review, we’ll compare the key features and benefits of the Dogtra 1900S and ARC e-collars. Discover which model is best for your dog’s size, temperament and training environment.
Overview of Dogtra Remote Training Collars
Dogtra has been a leading manufacturer of dog training equipment for over 30 years. Their e-collars are known for providing precise, customizable stimulation levels to suit any dog.
Dogtra e-collars deliver a brief static correction to get your dog’s attention and reinforce commands from a distance. The stimulation levels start very low and increase gradually, ensuring safety.
Unlike shock collars of the past, modern remote trainers like the Dogtra Pathfinder 2 use much gentler stimulation that is designed to get your dog’s focus, not hurt them. Proper e-collar training should involve no more than a tingle sensation.
Dogtra e-collars are ideal for:
- Reinforcing obedience commands like recall, heel and place from a distance
- Controlling problem behaviors like excessive barking, chasing or digging
- Training hunting, field and competition dogs to steady and focus off-leash
- Providing a remote leash for hiking, beaches and other open areas
With features like waterproof receivers, rechargeable batteries and extended range, Dogtra e-collars allow you to train anywhere.
Now let’s take a closer look at two of Dogtra’s most popular models.
Dogtra 1900S E-Collar Overview
The Dogtra 1900S is Dogtra’s best selling e-collar and most versatile training tool. With its adjustable stimulation levels and 1/2 mile range, the 1900S can reinforce obedience in most average dogs in various environments.
Key Features:
- 127 stimulation levels – Start as low as 1 and increase incrementally as needed
- 1/2 mile range – Ample range for most training scenarios
- Low to high power output – For dogs as small as 15 lbs up to 125 lbs
- Nick or constant stimulation – Momentary nick or continuous stimulation up to 12 seconds
- Fully waterproof – Train anywhere, even wet conditions
- Rechargeable batteries – Last 2-3 hours per charge
- Expandable to 2 dogs – Purchase add-on collar for 2 dog system
The 1900S is Dogtra’s most versatile model suitable for basic obedience to competition training. With proper use, the 1900S can reinforce commands in all but the most stubborn dogs.
Dogtra ARC E-Collar Overview
The Dogtra ARC (Advanced Receiver Concept) takes Dogtra’s e-collar technology and packs it into a smaller, more ergonomic receiver. Designed for comfort and discretion, the ARC is great for urban pets.
Key Features:
- 100 stimulation levels – Start from 1 for the most sensitive dogs
- 1/2 mile range – Consistent with other Dogtra models
- Low to medium power output – For smaller dogs from 10-70 lbs
- Nick or constant stimulation – Both momentary and continuous options
- Fully waterproof – Train anywhere including wet conditions
- Rechargeable batteries – Last 2-3 hours per charge
- Expandable to 2 dogs – Add a second collar receiver
With its petite receiver size and lower stimulation output, the ARC is ideal for small to medium dogs that require less power.
Now that we’ve covered the basics, let’s compare some key factors in choosing between these two excellent e-collars.
Dogtra 1900S vs ARC: Key Feature Comparison
While both are quality remote training collars, the 1900S and ARC have some notable differences when it comes to stimulation levels, power output and features.
Stimulation Range
Dogtra 1900S
The Dogtra 1900S and the Dogtra ARC both feature 127 stimulation levels.
This uniformity in the range of both models allows for more nuanced corrections. You can find just the right stimulation that gets your dog’s attention without overpowering them in either device.
Having 127 levels in both the 1900S and ARC may provide more fine-tuning options. And for sensitive dogs, having levels start at 1 is important to establish an appropriate baseline, which is now a feature of both models.
Stimulation Power Output
The 1900S has a higher maximum power output than the ARC. The 1900S is adjustable from low to high stimulation appropriate for dogs from 15-125 lbs.
Comparatively, the ARC has a low to medium power output suitable for smaller dogs from 10-70 lbs.
If your dog is over 70 lbs and very high drive, the 1900S may be a better choice. For smaller, less high strung dogs, the ARC’s power output should suffice.
Collar Receiver Size
The ARC has a smaller collar receiver than the 1900S. The ARC receiver width is about 1.25 inches versus 2 inches for the 1900S.
The ARC’s petite receiver is designed to be lightweight and hug the dog’s neck. This makes it ideal for smaller breeds that don’t require a lot of power.
The 1900S receiver is still modest in size but may look and feel more substantial on toy breeds or dogs with slender necks.
Waterproof Rating
Both the 1900S and ARC are fully waterproof and can be submerged up to 10 feet. This allows you to train near water or in wet conditions confidently.
Batteries and Runtime
The 1900S and ARC both feature rechargeable Lithium Polymer batteries that last around 2-3 hours per charge. The rechargeable batteries are far more cost effective than replaceable batteries.
Warranty
The 1900S and ARC come with 2 year warranties on workmanship and defects. This protects your investment should any issues arise.
Cost
The ARC is generally a bit less expensive than the 1900S. Both offer excellent value for quality e-collars, but the ARC is the more budget friendly option.
Dogtra 1900S vs ARC: Which is Better For Your Dog?
When trying to decide between the 1900S and the ARC, there are a few key considerations to keep in mind:
Your Dog’s Size
The ARC’s smaller receiver and lower power output make it the better choice for small to medium sized dogs (10-70 lbs). For larger dogs, the 1900S provides more power as needed.
Your Dog’s Temperament
High drive, high energy and stubborn dogs often benefit from the higher power 1900S to reinforce commands.
For milder, less stubborn personalities, the ARC’s lower stimulation is less likely to overpower them.
Training Environment
The ARC excels for urban pets as the streamlined receiver is less conspicuous and blends in like a regular collar.
For rural training and field work, the 1900S’ higher output has the advantage for range and overcoming distractions.
Additional Models to Consider
Beyond the standard 1900S and ARC, Dogtra makes remotes with specialized features that may suit your needs:
- 1900S-HV – 3/4 mile range for wide open training
- ARC Handsfree – Add a waist belt controller for handsfree use
- 1900M – Miniature version for very small dogs
- 1900S Black 4.0 – Special “boost” feature for extra stimulation
- 2300NCP – For competition obedience and agility dogs
- Pathfinder II – GPS enhanced model with 9 mile range for field dogs
Consider your specific training goals and environment to narrow down which model best fits your dog. Having the right e-collar makes achieving solid obedience much easier.
Also read: Dogtra ARC vs 280C E-Collar Comparison.
Top Tips For Picking The Right Dogtra E-Collar
- Match the power output to your dog’s size – high for large dogs, low/medium for small dogs.
- Factor in your dog’s temperament and sensitivity – mild dogs need less stimulation.
- Consider the training areas and range you need access to.
- Pick rechargeable lithium batteries for cost savings and convenience.
- Ensure the collar receiver is appropriately sized for a snug, secure fit.
- Buy from authorized dealers to ensure warranty coverage. Avoid 3rd party sellers.
- Read, understand and follow operational guides thoroughly before use.
- Always start on the lowest stimulation level and adjust upwards slowly as needed.
- Ensure proper collar tightness and contact points for effectiveness and safety.
- Remove the receiver after training sessions and check your dog’s neck.
- Only use the e-collar for the recommended duration per session.
- Train using positive reinforcement, setting your dog up for success. The e-collar is for occasional reinforcement only.
For more on how the Dogtra compares to other popular models like the Halo, check out this comparison of the Dogtra vs Halo.
Conclusion
The Dogtra 1900S and ARC represent two outstanding options when choosing an e-collar. Both are backed by Dogtra’s reputation for quality and customer support.
For larger, driven dogs that require more power, the 1900S is the way to go. If you have a smaller dog with a softer personality, the ARC shines.
Whichever Dogtra model you choose, be sure to take the time to properly introduce your dog to the e-collar. With proper training, an e-collar is a safe, effective training tool that every owner can master. Your dog will quickly learn the power of this “virtual leash” for reliable obedience on and off leash.
